Will Paige return in WWE WrestleMania 42? Fans push for AJ Lee and Alexa Bliss feuds amid Saraya's comeback buzz

Supratik | Apr 18, 2026, 03:04 IST
Share
Paige’s reported WWE return in April 2026 has sparked massive fan buzz, with WrestleMania 42 emerging as a potential stage for her comeback. After her AEW run as Saraya, the former Divas Champion now re-enters a stacked women’s division, with fans already speculating dream feuds, emotional storylines, and a second act that could reshape her legacy.
Paige WWE Return Buzz Grows Before Mania 42<br>
Image credit : Inside Pulse | Paige return rumors spark dream feud frenzy
WWE Wrestlemania 42 nears closer, and it is continuing to send shock waves across the world of wrestling. It seems that there will soon be a return of one of the most prominent stars of the WWE women's revolution era.

According to wrestling media outlet PWInsider, Saraya (otherwise known as Paige) has signed a new contract with WWE, which goes into effect on April 18, 2026. Having left WWE four years ago because of the expiry of her contract, as well as her absence from any in-ring activity caused by the career-threatening neck injury she sustained in 2018, influenced a movie as well, named “Fighting with My Family”, portrayed by Florence Pugh. Paige is going to come full circle and join WWE, the company which has changed significantly without her in the last few years.

Indeed, in recent years, her life and career were anything but dull, especially in All Elite Wrestling, where she competed under her maiden name from 2022 to 2025, even winning the AEW Women’s World Championship and thus showing the world that she can still deliver. However, the news of her re-signing with WWE makes people think about her possible comeback around WrestleMania 42.


How did the Paige-WWE link-up resurface again?

According to recent reports from PWInsider, Paige re-signed with WWE on April 18, 2026, signaling the end of her time away from the company and the beginning of a highly anticipated return.

Although the specifics of her contract are yet to be disclosed to the public, the decision seems to be the culmination of a period of success she has experienced while wrestling for All Elite Wrestling (AEW).

However, from an insider perspective, it does not seem like Paige's return has been hastily executed. On the contrary, it seems to have been well thought out, possibly as part of a long-term storyline planned by WWE, especially around the time WrestleMania 42 is scheduled to take place in the next few hours. Her medical qualifications and legacy in WWE mean that she will be treated with great consideration upon her return. This signing was far more than what it appeared on the surface.


Who can Paige feud with?

The potential feud with Alexa Bliss seems to be quite natural, especially because both parties can offer an engaging narrative, and the plot is likely to work well for the title storyline. Moreover, Liv Morgan's involvement is another intriguing option because this personality brings unpredictability to the storyline, which may help reveal a different side of the character.

Another potential idea is the generational conflict, which implies that the debut may imply a conflict between the old-school wrestler and the new generation. A past vs present narrative may be on the cards as Stephanie Vaquer is among the personalities who may become Paige's opponent.

However, the most intriguing idea is the legacy rivalry with AJ Lee. In general, the rivalry is already quite interesting for the audience, so the potential return may increase interest in the show considerably. Thus, although nothing is confirmed, many potential options can provide an interesting rivalry for Paige.


‘Paige is coming home’: Fans cannot keep calm

Fans on X quickly lit up at reports of Paige returning to WWE, with reactions like “Paige back? This is the comeback we needed,” and “Give me Paige vs Alexa Bliss at WrestleMania ASAP.”

Some pushed for nostalgia, “Paige vs AJ Lee one last time”, while others urged caution: “Just hope they protect her this time.” Overall, the buzz is loud, emotional, and already fantasy-booking her next move.


What's next?: Defining second act or carefully scripted comeback?

Everyone's watching how Paige makes her way back to WWE. It looks like WrestleMania 42 might be the perfect place to kick things off, either by surprising everyone with her arrival or setting her up for a storyline.

After Paige returns, what she does next becomes the priority. Either she'll have a slow and safe reintroduction into the ring, or she'll immediately jump into a heated rivalry. With all the talent already in the women's division, WWE will have to figure out how to make her fit in. But when done correctly, this could be more than a simple comeback. It could be the seed planted for her renewed legacy.
Follow us
Contact