Finished A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder Season 2? Here are 5 must watch mystery series packed with secrets And shocking twists

Netflix's A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder quickly became one of the most talked about young adult mystery series in recent years. With Pip Fitz Amobi digging into hidden secrets, old crimes, and dangerous truths, the show delivered a mix of suspense, emotion, romance, and clever detective work that kept viewers hooked.


Now that Season 2 has arrived, many fans are already looking for their next mystery obsession. If you love stories packed with twists, unreliable suspects, shocking revelations, and young investigators chasing the truth, these five shows deserve a place on your watchlist.

• Platform: Netflix (Seasons 1 to 3 in many regions), Hulu and other streaming platforms depending on location
• Episode Count: 4 Seasons, 72 Episodes

Long before Pip Fitz Amobi arrived on screen, Veronica Mars set the standard for teen detective dramas. Kristen Bell stars as Veronica, a smart and determined high school student who works as a private investigator while navigating life in a wealthy California town filled with corruption, secrets, and crime.

Each season combines an overarching mystery with smaller investigations, making every episode feel rewarding. The show balances murder cases, family drama, friendships, and romance in a way that feels natural and engaging. Fans of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder will appreciate Veronica's sharp instincts, fearless attitude, and willingness to challenge powerful people to uncover the truth.

• Platform: Netflix in many countries, Peacock in the United States
• Episode Count: 2 Seasons, 16 Episodes

Based on Karen M. McManus's bestselling novel, One of Us Is Lying begins with five students entering detention and only four leaving alive. When one teenager dies unexpectedly, the remaining students become prime suspects.


As the investigation unfolds, every character is forced to confront hidden secrets and personal lies. The series constantly shifts suspicion from one person to another, keeping viewers guessing until the very end.

The fast pacing and high school setting make it an ideal follow up for viewers who enjoyed the combination of teen drama and murder mystery in A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.

• Platform: Paramount+
• Episode Count: 3 Seasons, 24 Episodes

School Spirits takes the traditional mystery formula and adds a supernatural twist. The story follows Maddie Nears, a teenager who suddenly finds herself trapped in the afterlife and determined to solve the mystery of her own disappearance.

While helping investigate what happened to her, Maddie uncovers secrets involving friends, family members, classmates, and teachers. The series blends humour, emotion, and suspense surprisingly well.

What makes School Spirits stand out is its ability to mix heartfelt coming of age storytelling with a genuinely compelling mystery. Fans who enjoyed Pip's determination will likely connect with Maddie's relentless search for answers.

• Platform: Hulu, Disney+ in selected regions, and Prime Video in some international markets
• Episode Count: 2 Seasons, 20 Episodes

Cruel Summer is one of the most underrated mystery thrillers of recent years. The first season follows two teenage girls whose lives become connected after one mysteriously disappears.

The story unfolds across multiple timelines, gradually revealing new pieces of information that completely change viewers' understanding of events. Every episode introduces fresh clues while raising even more questions.

Much like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, the show challenges assumptions and forces audiences to rethink what they believe is true. Its layered storytelling rewards viewers who pay close attention.

• Platform: Max
• Episode Count: 2 Seasons, 18 Episodes

Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin reinvents the popular franchise with a darker and more suspenseful approach. Set in the town of Millwood, the series follows a group of teenage girls targeted by a mysterious figure connected to secrets from their parents' past.

Unlike the original series, this version leans more heavily into horror and psychological thriller elements. The danger feels more immediate, and the mysteries become increasingly intense as the story progresses. Viewers who loved the paranoia, pressure, and constant twists in A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder will find plenty to enjoy here.


If you want a classic detective story with multiple seasons, Veronica Mars remains the strongest recommendation. Viewers looking for a shorter binge should start with One of Us Is Lying, while School Spirits offers a unique supernatural spin on the mystery genre.

Cruel Summer is perfect for fans who enjoy complex timelines and unreliable narrators. Meanwhile, Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin delivers darker thrills and a higher level of tension.

No matter which show you choose, each one captures the ingredients that made A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder such a success: compelling young characters, gripping mysteries, emotional stakes, and twists that keep audiences guessing until the final reveal.